an idea to solve the "Mecca is in the north and Muslims are going to the wrong place"

a brother maybe a sister? posted a video of Tom Holland the historian saying that we have the wrong mecca.

there is no need to make the case for our claim that mecca is mecca. we just need to prove it can't be in the north. just mess with the other claims and by deduction like Holmes says Once you eliminate the impossible, whatever remains, no matter how improbable, must be the truth.

now i'm just an anthropologist and i can't build a case without help. if we pool what we know maybe we can build a case. most of what we need are a strong claim that was in the south pretty much. we don't need to prove its in the east because of alkharamita how broke the black stone and kept it in al ehsa and bahrain why return it to the west if it was from the east. we don't need to prove its in the west because mecca is in the west of Arabia. we need a claim of strong relation to the south. something the north didn't know but the south did, but the trump card would be a proven document that shows the 1st hijra or the king of aksuim knew where the 1st muhajirine came from. alternatively abraha is a proven figure in history. wiki says some recently found deviance shows that he died in a last expedition.

if we can prove that the north didn't know about him then we have proof. if we do we have to beat them to the punch, show the claim for the joke that it is.

a paper with a titles of the magician Mecca, the incoherent rambling of the orientalist.

or where is waldo's Mecca, a history of incoherence. just to be clear Mecca is used to describe almost any cite other than Mecca. the jokes are on the "historians" not on the holy lands

submitted by /u/buzaed1
[link] [comments]

from Islam https://ift.tt/3h1IQyp